"Daman da aka rasa 39 ga Satumba". An rasa damar don haƙiƙanin hangen nesa
"Daman da aka rasa 39 ga Satumba". An rasa damar don haƙiƙanin hangen nesa
Rubutun bitar littafin "Damarar da aka rasa" SEPTEMBER'39, wani abu mai mahimmanci wanda ke nuna rashin girmamawa ga kwamandojin Poland da ke da alhakin yakin yakin Jamhuriyar Poland ta biyu, da kuma wasu maganganu da yawa waɗanda ba su dace da dokoki ba. na tattaunawa ta kimiyya ko ta jarida, ba shine abu mafi dadi a yi ba.
Marubucin a fili ya nuna rashin gamsuwa da sakamakon aikin masana tarihi da suka yi magana game da tsarin makamai na Poland shekaru da yawa kuma suna neman wani baya. Ta hanyar zuba jarurruka a cikin wani tsari mai mahimmanci na sake dawowa, yana so ya ƙirƙira sabon tsarin, don juya yakin tsaro a cikin nasara, wanda, duk da haka, ba zai iya zuwa a cikin rikici da Jamus da Tarayyar Soviet ba.
Ƙarshen littafin: Mun sami damar ƙira da samar da isassun makaman da suka dace, da kuma sanya su cikin sabis. Koyaya, an rasa waɗannan damar. Kuma ba don dalilai na kuɗi ko fasaha ba - ba shi da wani mahimmanci.
Ba na ganin godiyar da marubucin ya yi game da manyan nasarorin da jamhuriyar Poland ta biyu ta samu a wancan lokaci ya yi yawa; a ra'ayinsa, sau da yawa sukan zama gazawa. A halin yanzu, kasancewar kasa mai rauni ta yi nasarar aiwatar da irin wannan tsari mai girma da kuma irin wannan shiri na zuba jari da makamai bai kamata ya haifar da abin kunya ba, sai alfahari. Marubucin ya gina tsarin karya na mafi kyawun rubutun nasa, kuma littafinsa yana nuna munanan halaye da ruɗi, tunani da ji na ɗabi'a, galibi lalata wallafe-wallafen lokacin rahoton. Har ila yau, kuna samun ƙungiyoyin kasashen waje: Faransanci ba tare da kunya ba. daga cikinsu [wato. masana tarihi] sun yi hannun riga da ilmin lissafi (shafi na 80), matakin sanin abokanmu (...) abin kunya ne (shafi na 71). Don haka kowane shafuka kaɗan. Wani lokaci muna saduwa da irin wannan kalma sau da yawa, har ma a kan shafi ɗaya: PZL R-72a "Hawk" gaba daya mara nasara ..., kuma "Wolf" mara nasara (shafi na 78). Wani lokaci Mawallafin ya kan ɓace a cikin tsokanarsa: tsoro ya gurgunta kusan dukkanin ikon Poland (shafi na 188), kada su taɓa yin mulkin wani abu fiye da kotun ƙauye (shafi na 50).
Waɗannan ƙa'idodi ne na zalunci da rashin adalci. Don haka, marubucin ba ya ƙarfafa jayayya kan ƙa'idodin da aka yarda da su - amma idan aka yi la'akari da cutar da mutane masu daraja da yawa, ina tsammanin wannan binciken ba zai iya kasancewa ba tare da amsawa ba. Babu shakka wannan littafi ba a rubuta shi ta mahangar hazikin mai lura da nazari na gaskiya ba.
Wanene wannan mutumin, a hankali, yana ba da shaida marar kyau? Ban sani ba, amma yarda da kansa da kuma sau da yawa ra'ayin son zuciya, hade da rashin boye niyyarsa na wulakanta mutane, ba zai iya zama wata hujja ta gaskiya ba.
Ba mu lura da wani aiki a cikin ma'ajin; wannan wani nau'i ne na sarrafa abin da wasu suka rubuta - amma kawai waɗanda marubucin ya zaɓa a matsayin jagora. Watakila bai kamata marubucin ya yi nuni da yadda ya kamata littafin adabin da ya shafi muhimman al’amura a fagen tsaron kasa ya kasance ba, duk da haka, ya dace ya nuna ayyukan Prof. Prof. Janusz Cisek, Marek Jablonowski, Wojciech Wlodarkiewicz, Piotr Stawiecki, Marek Galentzowski, Bohdan Musial, likitoci Timoteusz Pawlowski, Wojciech Mazur, janar Jozef Vyatr, Alexander Litvinovich, Vaclav Stakhevich da sauran marubuta da yawa. Har ila yau, zai zama wajibi ne don samun maganganun Stanisław Trushkowski, Adam Kurowski, nazarin shirin Janar Tadeusz Piskor, shirin shekaru uku 1933-1935/6 (don jirgin sama) da kuma gudanar da Rundunar Sojan Sama a cikin na gaba ɗaya. da dai sauransu. To me za a ce game da gaskiya?
Yana da wuya a gane dalilin da ya sa nuna rashin jin daɗi da yawa maki daga sabon wallafe-wallafen da muhimmanci sosai aiki na Ryszard Bartel, Jan Chojnicki, Tadeusz Krulikiewicz da Adam Kurowski "Daga tarihin Yaren mutanen Poland soja jirgin sama 1918-1939" 1978 aka maimaita.
